GTA 6: Should You Kill or Spare Arnold? What Each Choice Changes

By · Published

Spoiler note: this covers one early Chapter 1 mission and the single choice in it. Nothing later in the story is mentioned.

Short answer: it doesn’t change the story. Whether you shoot Arnold or let him go, he’s out of the game for good and you get the same reward. The only difference guides have reported is how the choice counts toward Jason’s criminal profile.

Where the choice comes up

The mission is Hey Arnold!, an early Chapter 1 job from Brian Heder. On the map it’s labeled “Meet Brian.” You play as Jason.

Brian’s broker, Arnold, has stopped returning his calls. The mission goes like this:

  1. Meet Brian, then pick up Cal.
  2. Find Arnold. He runs.
  3. Chase him by car. Riders on motorbikes get involved, and you’ll be shooting from the truck.
  4. Follow him across the bridge, where the truck takes some big jumps.
  5. Chase him on foot to the docks.
  6. Jason confronts him. Then the game hands you the decision.

What happens if you kill Arnold

Jason shoots him on the dock. Arnold is gone. No guide reports a payout, an item or an extra scene for doing it.

What happens if you spare Arnold

Arnold swims away and isn’t seen again. Jason tells Brian that Arnold won’t be a problem, and Brian accepts that. Again, no payout, item or extra scene has been reported.

So what’s actually different?

Kill Spare
Arnold later in the story Gone Gone
Reward Same Same
Brian’s reaction Satisfied Satisfied
Criminal profile Counts as the violent option Counts as the restrained option

Guides don’t agree on the profile labels. GAMES.GG calls the outcomes Hardened for killing and Restrained for sparing. Beebom describes killing as registering violent behavior. VGC’s writers shot Arnold and reported no consequence beyond the profile change.

So pick based on the Jason you’re building, not on a reward.

Which should you choose?

  • Playing Jason as controlled and professional? Spare him.
  • Playing Jason as ruthless? Kill him.
  • Only care about rewards and 100%? It makes no difference. The mission counts either way.

Want to see both?

GTA 6 has no mission replay, so you can’t go back from the menu. Make a manual save before you start the mission. You can’t save once it’s running. Details in how to save.

What the mission unlocks

Finishing Hey Arnold! unlocks the Bombara S23 Riverboat. That doesn’t depend on your choice.

Sources

Outcomes of both choices from GTA Base and eGamers. Mission flow from Beebom. Criminal profile effects from GAMES.GG, Beebom and VGC. These are launch-week reports. If a later consequence turns up, we’ll update this page.

Weekly prize: win the Play Journal free. The top score of the week in the daily trivia takes home the $8.99 download.5 questions a day · free to play · play today →

Keep reading